1

Topic: Whodunnit?

Whodunnit?

http://i.imgur.com/JKhf8Lk.jpg

I was a huge fan of The Mole and while Whodunnit? isn't as good imo it's not terrible either.

Anyone else watch this? I have a theory on who is the killer and would like to hear other ppl's ideas.

2

Re: Whodunnit?

Seeing how The Mole is the only reality show I watched and didn't hate I will check it out.

3

Re: Whodunnit?

i saw the first episode and i do like how it's setup.  A CLUE reality show is pretty entertatining.

4

Re: Whodunnit?

Ulysses is my guess.

5

Re: Whodunnit?

My guess is Lyndsey (The "dumb" blonde with big horse teeth)

6

Re: Whodunnit?

Yeah she's my second choice. I made my guess half way threw the first episode, and just had even more reason to stick with him after the second episode.

The show really does seem like a poor mans version of The Mole.

7

Re: Whodunnit?

I think the first two shows been fun.

At the first line up i decided to pick out my prime suspect and i went for Geno.
So far i think the "killer" will not be within the two scared people nor the top scorer. Would be strange if he/she was and that would make it rigged.
So i am going to exclude those from my suspicions.

I still feel that Geno is a top choice

Been trying to find a girl suspect too but so far i think only Chris is a strong suspect. I will try to look more for Lyndsey in the coming episodes

8

Re: Whodunnit?

Rwings wrote:

I made my guess half way threw the first episode

Same here, I got this gut feeling about 15-20 mins in about Lyndsey and the more I watched the more I was convinced.

Geno is a good possibility, but personally I don't suspect Ulysses b/c he comes off as a strong player (winning top guess in ep 2) and I don't think the killer would try to attract that much attention this early. I think the killer is gonna be someone who blends in and we hardly even know is there most of the time, like Lynsey.  cool
Although there is an argument for the opposite, so it may be Ulysses to throw off ppl who think like me lol.

And speaking of The Mole, I just found out the Aussie version of The Mole started Season 6, there's 2 eps I found online. I had no idea there even was an Aussie version lol. I hope it's as good as the US version or better.

9 (edited by Rwings 2013-07-03 21:11:19)

Re: Whodunnit?

I really liked the first season of The Mole especially the three that made it to the final. I might need to check out the Aussie version

Edit: Found the first episode of season 1 of the Aussie version http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-zD3R0Y500

10

Re: Whodunnit?

i'm gonna put my money on kam, but y'know depending on how well they do in the game the produces will pick whoever is the best for the "killer" role.  Sad to say i'm actually excited to see wut happens next on this reality show..... and i secretly wanna see some of those bitches die ;-)

11

Re: Whodunnit?

poncherello wrote:

depending on how well they do in the game the produces will pick whoever is the best for the "killer" role.

I don't they can do that without seriously screwing up the game. I'm pretty sure the killer was picked way b4 the show started and is paid based on how well they can deceive the others, similar to the Mole.

12

Re: Whodunnit?

The difference though is on The Mole the person was an active player in trying to derail the events. In this show the 'killer' I don't think has done any of the killings. As in they haven't done anything to get caught in the act to make guessing the person possible.

I mean I could be just reading the show wrong, but I just don't see what the purpose of the killer is yet. The show so far just seems to be figuring out how the killings happen and guessing who the killer is seems kind of an after thought. I will be surprise if the role of the killer actually becomes something worth while.

13

Re: Whodunnit?

Yeah i'm not 100% sure, but i dont see the game working if they determined the killer before hand.  I believe everyone has a chance to win the prize at the end, but the killer will end up being one of the dead people in the final four or something like that.  Where he'll fake his own death to keep the remaining players guess who it is ;-)

14

Re: Whodunnit?

Well I think they had to pick a killer at some point or the entire premise of the show would be a sham. The killings are to easy to figure out as it is, that the only reason to watch is just to see how exactly the killer plays a part of the show. They could of done a letter better job at framing the concept of the show, because right now I just don't see the point.

15

Re: Whodunnit?

I agree that at this point finding the killer does seem to be an after thought to the way the killings are done but I still strongly believe that the show wouldn't work if the killer was not picked beforehand. While we haven't seen any blatant correlation to the killer and a player, I hope by the end we will start to see clues that will link a player to the killings.
I think the killer has been trying to stay under the radar in the early eps but I think as the numbers dwindle the killer will be forced to make bigger moves and leave bigger clues.
Also, I do think it is more similar to the Mole than you b/c I think the killer is an active player trying to derail people's thoughts on the killings by feeding false info or withholding key info from ppl when they can. I agree the killer probably has not done any of the actual killings but I think the clues will eventually reveal killer by the end.
Then again I may be completely wrong on all fronts lol
These r just my thoughts  cool

16

Re: Whodunnit?

All I know is the the old white chick that has been 'scared' two weeks in a row needs to go she's useless. So is the black girl. Once those two are out then I would like to she the blonde who you think is the killer to go if she is indeed not the killer. The remaining players are more interesting and I find to be less annoying than the three I listed.

As for the killing playing an active role, I mean I guess it's possible, but why would the killer be giving clues to how it's done while also trying to stop the killing from being found out. It would make more sense if the one giving the clues was a third party trying to help uncover the murderer and then the murderer would be trying to stop that from happening. The way it's set up right now just makes the killer seem bi-polar.

17

Re: Whodunnit?

hehe i do like the game they play though, but you really just have to tune in at the end, cause the best part is where they kill someone... i might be messed up in the head, but i can't wait to see them kill off some certain members of the game.

18

Re: Whodunnit?

The previews make it look like it will be  G-no or you know whatever is name is will be next. Looked like a big guy being thrown off the horse.

19

Re: Whodunnit?

Rwings wrote:

The previews make it look like it will be  G-no or you know whatever is name is will be next. Looked like a big guy being thrown off the horse.

i thought the same thing but the previews r usually deceiving in the way they edit it so I wont be surprised if it's someone else

20 (edited by jackolantern 2013-07-11 23:44:17)

Re: Whodunnit?

The Butler did it

21

Re: Whodunnit?

If the Butler did it, that would actually make sense compared to what the other options are.

My guess is still Ulyse-Bible Blonde-Other Blonde, Kris I think

22

Re: Whodunnit?

I thought Cris would be a good killer at the start but if she was the killer i would expect her to try and move strange information between the two groups more than now. Kinda like Lindsey did in episode 3. I thought that made Lindsey look very suspicious.

A lot of people skip the previews to avoid spoilers.

23

Re: Whodunnit?

Ah I always forget what happen in the preview before the next episode airs, and the previews never tell the truth so it doesn't matter to me either way.

24

Re: Whodunnit?

Rwings wrote:

Ah I always forget what happen in the preview before the next episode airs, and the previews never tell the truth so it doesn't matter to me either way.

I always forget too lol

25

Re: Whodunnit?

I got the feeling in the last episode that the killer could be like someone from the Agatha Christie-book (spoiler from one particular book)

Spoiler

Ten Little Indians, were the killer were the one who was killed first

But I have thought of the butler too. I like the show.

(BTW it was a Norwegian Mole too, a long time ago).

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=218f9bd804e6df87fe43a8dd62158dbc