Topic: scrubs musical.... 6x06
for those of you who are interested..... scrub's musical episode was this current one....
not totally to my tastes.... but it was very cleverly done... and still had a good plot
- Nick
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
I was very tempted to stop watching... Its so fu*king irritating :S
- Orb
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
Not a big fan of musicals, but I rate this episode as the best so far of the season. That being said the other 5 episodes have for the most part been poor.
"Dayman. Fighter of the Nightman. Champion of the Sun. You're a master of Karate and friendship for everyone." --Electric Dream Machine
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
I guess I can see why many wouldn't like it. I loved it, but then again, I do go to music school. 
- knuckleskin
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
Dunno what show you've been watching but I think the last 5 episodes have been the strongest yet. The writers have managed to deal with very serious subjects in such an enlightening and entertaining way without losing any of the gravitas.
I thought this episode, on the other hand, was pretty poor, it was good, but in the end it just seemed a reason to throw in some known faces and escape from the normal story structure. The songs got to me after the 3rd one and I really did want to turn it off. They could have been more wittily written.
I hope this isn't the downturn of the curve.
An intelligent man knows lots of complicated words, a wise man knows not to use them.
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
You guys are nuts... First off, even if you didn't like this episode, you can take a deep breath, cause it was pretty much a one time thing... I personall thought this episode was pretty clever. The show is amazing, and once in a while they twist things up a bit, no biggie. So far this season has been great, it hasn't lost an ounce of the humour i started with in season 1.
- knuckleskin
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
In fact, I would proclaim that this season, they have clawed back the humour they lost in the intermediary seasons.
Just this last one grated against me, roll on next Friday.
An intelligent man knows lots of complicated words, a wise man knows not to use them.
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
I am now watching this shitty episode, I'm annoyed, hate this shit. This was NOT a good idea...hope this will be the last musical shit...!! Annoyed Scrubs enthusiast...
- Netto
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
How great was this episode, really love those musical episodes. Almost started singing along. "Guy Love" Lol, that was great!.
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
zero122 wrote:
You guys are nuts... First off, even if you didn't like this episode, you can take a deep breath, cause it was pretty much a one time thing... I personall thought this episode was pretty clever. The show is amazing, and once in a while they twist things up a bit, no biggie. So far this season has been great, it hasn't lost an ounce of the humour i started with in season 1.
I tend to agree with what Zero122 has said. Not the most plot breaking episode but as you can imagine preparation involved across the board, that in itself impressed me. They did something like this in Buffy I seem to remember but again most of the characters in both episodes could hold a tune and dance pretty well. I particularly liked the Poo song because I find toilet humour just tickles me every time. Guy Love also was very well done and funny.
They need to do more Janitor/JD episodes as they always seem to be the ones I find the funnies. The trouble is every character has become tiresome and stale and although some of the recent episode have been funny, I was watching some repeats on TV and they chemistry was still there. DON'T SAY BANANA HANNOCK!!!!
- HomerS
- TV Devil
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
i had really to struggle to watch it, concentration problems 
it was not bad but nothing against the musical episode of Buffy, now that was fantastic.
- knuckleskin
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
I see this episode is a bit marmite (7).
I personally love marmite, but not a fan of this episode.
An intelligent man knows lots of complicated words, a wise man knows not to use them.
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
I thought it was the best episode ever.
I am not a huge fan of musicals but this was so cleverly done that it deserves an emmy. Making good musicals is hard enough but making it funny as well? It was excellent!
- Orb
- Member
- Offline
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
1231 Diggs for the Guy Love song on YouTube indicates many others liked this episode too.
"Dayman. Fighter of the Nightman. Champion of the Sun. You're a master of Karate and friendship for everyone." --Electric Dream Machine
Re: scrubs musical.... 6x06
Doing a musical episode was not a bad idea, and it was carried out pretty solidly. It was not a bad episode.
Still I must say I was disappointed by that episode for several reasons.
1.) Knowing and treasuring the musical episode from Buffy, which had incredibly well-written and well-performed songs my expectations were quite high.
2.) Hearing that the songs would be written by the Avenue Q writers (BEST.MUSICAL.EVER) also pushed up those expectations. Yet with the exception of "Guy Love" none of the songs were particularly witty and the music just wasn't that exceptional.
3.) The plot was pretty thin, but that's what you would expect from a "very special episode". Still it would have loosened up the basic concept of "just stringing those songs together" if there were some half-songs from the extras to illustrate the all-around musical the world has been made to her by the girls condition. ("It isn't right it isn't fair! There was no parking anywhere, I think that hydrant wasn't there.")
4.) I just can't get over how great the musical episode from Buffy was, gotta watch it again 
Follow