26 (edited by xrnzaaas 2010-11-01 22:32:36)

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

It's certainly too early to review the series after only one episode. If the show wants to follow the comics it should get more and more depressing, brutal and shocking over time. That's what made the comic series special for me and I'm hoping for the same thing here. Pilot seemed ok and it seems to be heading in the right direction. I just hope that they don't turn it more into an action series. For example, the tank scene was not included in the comics and the tanks have appeared for the first time much later and in a different context. Same with military vehicles and choppers near the hospital, just itching you to use them and not present in the comics.

PS. In fact it was even dumb for Rick to choose a squad car over a humvee (I can understand that he doesn't have a pilot's license).

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=f2966a511fdd8bb4a428730b3f318478

27

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Well i loved the first episode smile Very well made, but one thing that kind of annoyed me was when he got shot the second time in the begining. Seriously if you are a cop dont you wait to turn your back against the suspects until your sure you have got everyone of them?


BlackBox wrote:

Just to be clear - this show is on my watchlist but not for long if it doesn't improve in the next episodes. I've seen so many zombie movies over the year and this is simply nothing new or done differently. If the rest is average survival drama I'm off.

Im not really sure how you can do a zombie apocalypse in a way that haven't already been done. But who gets tierd of zombies? big_smile Especially a tv show with zombies!

28

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

xrnzaaas wrote:

In fact it was even dumb for Rick to choose a squad car over a humvee

A humvee eats gas like a motherfucker. And in that situation, gas isn't that easy to get, y/y?

BlackBox wrote:

If the rest is average survival drama I'm off.

Well, it won't a be an action show with explosions and boobs, so bye bye.

http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/OrlandoNEP.png

29 (edited by xrnzaaas 2010-11-01 23:13:31)

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

It does, but judging from the comics lack of gas doesn't seem to be a HUGE problem for the main characters. I mean, it hasn't been years since the apocalypse and there aren't that many survivors. An old camper with bad mpg is an important part of the comic series and it doesn't bother them that it needs to be refuelled often.

Mirano wrote:

Well i loved the first episode smile Very well made, but one thing that kind of annoyed me was when he got shot the second time in the begining. Seriously if you are a cop dont you wait to turn your back against the suspects until your sure you have got everyone of them?

They were chasing a two-door vehicle so a third shooter wouldn't seem likely to me as well. smile Or that so many people would survive a crash in an old car with no modern safety features.

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=f2966a511fdd8bb4a428730b3f318478

30

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Orlando wrote:
BlackBox wrote:

If the rest is average survival drama I'm off.

Well, it won't a be an action show with explosions and boobs, so bye bye.

Oh I don't need that - just good acting and writing does the trick for me. I would more like a Jericho feeling wink

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=f2f78bbc2ae515f1a55746f794066001

31

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

BlackBox wrote:
Orlando wrote:
BlackBox wrote:

If the rest is average survival drama I'm off.

Well, it won't a be an action show with explosions and boobs, so bye bye.

Oh I don't need that - just good acting and writing does the trick for me. I would more like a Jericho feeling wink


Jericho with Zombies ftw

I think you are going to have to publicly apologize for your lack of faith in a few episodes BB tongue

32

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

xrnzaaas wrote:

It's certainly too early to review the series after only one episode. If the show wants to follow the comics it should get more and more depressing, brutal and shocking over time. That's what made the comic series special for me and I'm hoping for the same thing here. Pilot seemed ok and it seems to be heading in the right direction. I just hope that they don't turn it more into an action series. For example, the tank scene was not included in the comics and the tanks have appeared for the first time much later and in a different context. Same with military vehicles and choppers near the hospital, just itching you to use them and not present in the comics.

PS. In fact it was even dumb for Rick to choose a squad car over a humvee (I can understand that he doesn't have a pilot's license).

Well i dont know the comics, but his choice to take the police car was quite an obvious one. In the opening scene he show great skill in driving. Also the Hummer eats WAY to much gas. Also that in a zombie overrun city will be remains of military presence is also clear. The tank scene was AMAZING and great. I always thought why no other zombie movie did this, just climb in a freaking tank and ur safe for a while. I slept now one night over this pilot and its even looking better now.

33

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

taking a police car has imo also 2 effects. he is a cop. he of course takes a cop car. and amerikans trust their cops, so when there are survivors, they know who they are dealing with.

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist

34

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

That is true. I eould trust a police car more than a military vehicle.

http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/OrlandoNEP.png

35

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Orlando wrote:

That is true. I eould trust a police car more than a military vehicle.

now when to think about it, same here.

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist

36

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

He needs a 67 Impala smile)

http://next-episode.net/img/ne-link.png

http://i.imgur.com/6zvYE.jpg
http://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=fae192a45e22f2ea2fece89557aebb4c

37

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

BlackBox wrote:
Orlando wrote:
BlackBox wrote:

If the rest is average survival drama I'm off.

Well, it won't a be an action show with explosions and boobs, so bye bye.

Oh I don't need that - just good acting and writing does the trick for me. I would more like a Jericho feeling wink

So please tell me, and I'm asking without any sarcasm or anything, why bad/average writing is:

- Shooting your loved one to put him/her out of their misery.
- Killing a little girl.
- A scene of a couple that commited suicide with a sign out of blood (?) "God forgive us".
- Horrific body bags in the courtyard of the hospital.
- The night scene with the car alarm.
- The bicycle half-girl scene.
- The city scene with killing and eating a horse.

Also please remeber, that this comic is now quite old and when it was published, these "nothing new ideas" were new. Yes yes "then they should think of something new". But so what that it's "nothing new"? The world is done on a cinematic level, a lot of movies could say "sheit, I wish I was so perfectly done" because of the level of details and zombie designs. Last but not least, again, this show is not about killing zombies. It's about us, people, is such a gruesome situtation.

But I'll probably won't convice you anyways. All due respect, but I see your attitude towards this show.

http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/OrlandoNEP.png

38

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Spyder23 wrote:

He needs a 67 Impala smile)

And a Fed uniform. wink

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=f2966a511fdd8bb4a428730b3f318478

39

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

After much hype, anticipation, and promotion, AMC's The Walking Dead premiered last night, semi-appropriately on Halloween. It's not uncommon for shows with so much marketing behind them to disappoint. And given that The Walking Dead is an adaptation of a comic book much beloved by an incredibly discerning fan base, and there's plenty of reason to expect reviews summed up thusly: "The book was better."

Which is why I'm proud to say that The Walking Dead exceeded every expectation, even for those who are well ahead of the show's story because they've read what happens on the printed page. Taking a comic and converting it for the big screen is no small task, and producer Frank Darabont (Shawshank Redemption, The Green Mile) does a fine job retaining the comic's strengths and reinforcing its weaknesses.

My biggest beef with the comics is the rapid pace at which things happen (my second-biggest beef would be the dialogue). But that's a problem with the medium; you can't waste valuable panels taking the time to bridge things together. Darabont has successfully filled those gaps, intensifying the emotion and tension necessary to pull off The Walking Dead as a horror series. Admit it, you were peeking through your fingers at some parts. What that means, though, is a slower series than one might expect given the breakneck speed of the comics.

But the deliberate pace of The Walking Dead is actually an asset, and its stretched-out scenes are carefully planned so that, like those who are running in fear from the undead, all our available senses are being taxed. The Walking Dead uses sound better than any show I've seen heard recently, particularly in its eerie lack of noise. As Rick (a very able Andrew Lincoln) headed down the stairs toward the hospital exit and tiptoed among the dead, the only sound cues we heard were the desperate flicking and fizzling of matches, the hum of cicadas, and Bear McCreary's haunting score. It works. And it works well. Surround Sound and high-definition are a must.

The pace also reiterates what this story is about: how the human psyche copes with the destruction of all things we hold dear. The Walking Dead isn't about zombies; it's about the people who are surviving among them and the lengths those people will go to in order to survive. It's an honest-to-goodness character study, and that will be much more evident when we get to Episode 2.

We knew The Walking Dead would deviate from the comic, and for purists that can spell disaster. The show's sidesteps aren't yet drastic (we've only seen one episode, after all)—but for the television audience, so far they've only served the story better. One particular scene that was added—in which Morgan (Lennie James) took to the second story of his hideout with a sniper rifle and couldn't quite pull the trigger on his zombie wife—may have been the most difficult (and therefore awesome) scene to watch. The chatter between Shane and Rick at the beginning was also another addition that was necessary for television conversion, but it didn't feel tacked on. The trick to successfully turning a comic into a show is a matter of picking your fights, and Darabont has chosen wisely.

And oh the gore! I love me some splattered guts and flying brain matter, and The Walking Dead looks like a Megadeth album cover come to life. How many series do you know that make their first kill a little girl holding a teddy bear? Sure, she was a zombie, but still. And the gore isn't for shock value; it's necessary to the story and the way in which it's handled and shown on-screen is with much care. A special shout-out to the makeup and effects people is in order.

The Walking Dead has been described as a George Romero movie that doesn't end, and given the fact that the 90-minute first installment of the series encapsulated only about an issue and a half (the comic is currently somewhere in the high 70s or early 80s in number of issues), this series could go on for quite some time. I'll be watching. Next week: my boy Glenn!

http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/OrlandoNEP.png

40

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

godzionu wrote:
Orlando wrote:

That is true. I eould trust a police car more than a military vehicle.

now when to think about it, same here.

Choice of a police car is ok, but in the beginning when he leaves car and walks 200 meters to the gas station is stupid tactical mistake smile

What annoyed me was shooting zombies in the head from 10 cm distance, here @ 1:45 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufC4x4fcFaw you can see what happens in the real world wink

Same with a baseball bat - if you worry about scratches, in my opinion you should worry about zombie blood all over you too smile

Overall - good show wink

G:

41

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

monkgway wrote:

What annoyed me was shooting zombies in the head from 10 cm distance

uhh. it's hollywood. there things explode and have sound in space, etc...

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist

42

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Since I'm totally into Fallout New Vegas at the moment, the first thing that came to mind when he reached the military base with the choppers was: LOOOOOOOOTTTTT !!!

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=1cd1b92c236f3ba54cd38890b16399f4

43

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Btw these USA police cars are modified, they comes with heavy duty suspensions, protected engine compartment, extra batteries etc. - it's far from stock sedan wink

G:

44

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

xrnzaaas wrote:
Mirano wrote:

Well i loved the first episode smile Very well made, but one thing that kind of annoyed me was when he got shot the second time in the begining. Seriously if you are a cop dont you wait to turn your back against the suspects until your sure you have got everyone of them?

They were chasing a two-door vehicle so a third shooter wouldn't seem likely to me as well. smile Or that so many people would survive a crash in an old car with no modern safety features.

Still for me it didn't feel natural to turn your back and start talking, how could they even be sure the ones they shot really were dead and didn't fire at them again. But that's the only thing that bugged me, the rest were just awesome.

or well another thing that bugged me was the 720p version i downloaded, it looked like an average release, nothing HD about it. hmm

45

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

monkgway wrote:

Choice of a police car is ok, but in the beginning when he leaves car and walks 200 meters to the gas station is stupid tactical mistake smile

Or the road was blocked.

http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/OrlandoNEP.png

46

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

monkgway wrote:

Btw these USA police cars are modified, they comes with heavy duty suspensions, protected engine compartment, extra batteries etc. - it's far from stock sedan wink

not only US police cars. i know we here in Estonia have same things.

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist

47

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

Orlando wrote:
monkgway wrote:

Choice of a police car is ok, but in the beginning when he leaves car and walks 200 meters to the gas station is stupid tactical mistake smile

Or the road was blocked.

You can see that he easy can drive past these two cars smile And another thing - why he doesn't take fuel from other cars but like a princess wants to walk to the gas station when zombies lurks around? smile

G:

48

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

monkgway wrote:

And another thing - why he doesn't take fuel from other cars but like a princess wants to walk to the gas station when zombies lurks around? smile

ever seen a car nowadays? with all the filters and blockage, it's imo impossible to pump the gas out, unless you punch a hole inside the gas tank. but since they were talking in the beginning of the show about saving and protecting the planet i doubt he would do so that fast.

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist

49

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

godzionu wrote:
monkgway wrote:

And another thing - why he doesn't take fuel from other cars but like a princess wants to walk to the gas station when zombies lurks around? smile

ever seen a car nowadays? with all the filters and blockage, it's imo impossible to pump the gas out, unless you punch a hole inside the gas tank. but since they were talking in the beginning of the show about saving and protecting the planet i doubt he would do so that fast.

Yes, I have seen very many cars - these filters are no problem to take fuel, you always can easy penetrate a gas tank, specially in modern cars where gas tanks are made from plastic wink Plus many USA cars doesn't have filters and blockage at all - they are simple as brick smile

G:

50

Re: 1x01 - Days Gone Bye

monkgway wrote:

they are simple as brick smile

US cars have gas tanks made out of brick? http://imgur.com/WDQay.gif

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist