1

Topic: Who made the best live action Superman?

We seem to have an obsession with Superman vs Batman on this site, so I'm tackling the question from another perspective...

Which actor from the list do you think played the (arguably) most famous Superhero the best?


And yes, I know Gerard Christopher technically played Superboy, but what the hell...

2 (edited by hometimenow 2009-01-18 17:45:50)

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

I went the Tom.

Never actually heard of Kirk Alyn
edit: OR Gerard Christopher

I sleep through most or all of these tongue

http://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=27b3aae90777dd30de5cd9520ad96a66

3 (edited by z1rra 2009-01-18 17:59:44)

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

i only know 2 of them...went with the more famous one, Reeve that is.

E: next we should see if liking macs and superman and liking pc-s and batman have some sort of relation?

4

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Nah, that doesn't work.  I like Superman and PCs.  smile

5

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

yeah, but maybe you are an exception.

off topic...Hard boiled has like so many bodies!!!!one!!11elevene!!!11onehundredandeleven11!!

6

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Tom Welling

7

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Little bit of trivia - Tom Welling and I are the exact same age.  smile

8 (edited by Mxyzptlk 2009-01-18 21:29:07)

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Your birthday is april 26?


999 posts... next one's going to be big tongue

9

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Do we get the same poll for Batman?

big_smile

https://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=f2f78bbc2ae515f1a55746f794066001

10

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

You can't vote for Tom Welling as technically he isn't yet Superman and according to what the shows writers have to say, "no tights, no flight", might never be or at least not until the last seconds of season 8, .
Brandon Routh was good on his one outing so far.
So sentiment aside I went with Dean Cain.

"To be born English is to win the lottery of life." Cecil Rhodes 1853-1902
"The man was right." Maccool111 1955-20**
http://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=eb307b8950c5d3766bd38b4bee466c98

11

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Mxyzptlk wrote:

Your birthday is april 26?

Apr 26, 1977  smile

BlackBox wrote:

Do we get the same poll for Batman?

Yup!  smile

12

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

I went also for the most known,  Reeve.
haah KB you are like 4 months older than me tongue my b-day is on Aug 4, 1977 tongue

and Mxyzptlk congrats on your next post big_smile

"Avenge Me."
"Judgment Day is inevitable."
__________________________________________
My Watchlist

13

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Oh wow, you have the same birthday as my sister... well, except two years younger.  big_smile

So yeah Mxy, what are you planning for the big 1000?  I completely missed mine.

14

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

I'm going with Smallville smile

No kitty that's a bad kitty!
http://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=AllSeries&kk=5f836862ea58dc1c953ce514ed6e5647
http://data.die2nite.com/gfx/loc/en/105x39.gif

15

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

i'm boycotting this poll... tongue

seriously... much as i find superman the most boring character out there, i do have a soft spot for those old black and white serials...

i'm going to eat your brains and gain your memories...

16

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Why boycott then - just vote for Kirk or George.  smile

17

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

oh i voted for George... just thought i'd remind you all of my feelings towards superman... i don't know why you even have a poll featuring superman... he's a redundancy in the world of superheroes... and we all know batman would kick him to the curb anyday...

i'm going to eat your brains and gain your memories...

18

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Well if you read above you'll know I'm doing a similar poll on Batman next.  tongue

19

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

you just like pissing off NC don't you TC tongue

No kitty that's a bad kitty!
http://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=AllSeries&kk=5f836862ea58dc1c953ce514ed6e5647
http://data.die2nite.com/gfx/loc/en/105x39.gif

20

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

i do try... yuhuh...

i'm going to eat your brains and gain your memories...

21

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

He has to live up his title, afterall.

22 (edited by nightcrow 2009-01-19 11:27:34)

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

theConundrumm wrote:

oh i voted for George... just thought i'd remind you all of my feelings towards superman... i don't know why you even have a poll featuring superman... he's a redundancy in the world of superheroes... and we all know batman would kick him to the curb anyday...

A fools words.... wink i'll elegantly ignore that ridiculous comment.

Btw, I voted Chris Reeve. Clearly best Supes ever! plus, if he were alive, he would use a mac! wink

Brothers! What we do in life...Echoes in Eternity!


http://next-episode.net/sig/sig.php?alias=default&kk=9a35ebe93d371275706bdebcafefaa47

23

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Hey, where's the Ben Affleck option? He too played Superman, sort of wink.

24

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

Nah, he's be in a two person poll for "Who played the best George Reeves?".  And since the other person would be George Reeves, somehow I think he'd lose.  Which would be funny, but probably not worth the poll.  wink

25

Re: Who made the best live action Superman?

karenbear wrote:

Nah, he's be in a two person poll for "Who played the best George Reeves?".  And since the other person would be George Reeves, somehow I think he'd lose.  Which would be funny, but probably not worth the poll.  wink

Do it! It's so worth it! (Just do mine first) tongue