You are not logged in. Please login or register.
Active topics Unanswered topics
Pages Previous 1 … 5 6 7
You must login or register to post a reply
RSS topic feed
Posts: 151 to 163 of 163

- jim1961
- Member
- Offline
- From: Texas
- Registered: 2025-02-24
- Posts: 276
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote:The Lord of The Rings: The Rings of Power - Season 3 Teaser | Prime Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmS7WuI9u40 At this point and with the context of this show I no longer see any reason to call Galadriel an elf...just a human with pointy ears...
That is what I have thought of all the elves in the show. WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote:with each season my opinion of her worsens and this trailer did not help there.
The trailer had so little of her, what didnt help about it? Did I miss something? WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote:No hobbits in the trailer...this has me worried as well.
I am just fine without them. I got enough of them in the original trilogy to last me a lifetime 
152 Reply by jim1961 2026-11-11 13:18:36 (edited by jim1961 2026-11-11 13:40:28)

- jim1961
- Member
- Offline
- From: Texas
- Registered: 2025-02-24
- Posts: 276
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
I was one of those that thoroughly enjoyed the 1st trilogy. But everything that has followed just hasn't grabbed me. Despite not being a fan of The Rings of Power through the first two seasons, I had gained some limited excitement about the coming of S3. Well, I just finished the first 4 episodes. Better than S2 for sure, but still nowhere close to what I like about the first trilogy. Maybe its me. Maybe I carry some invisible bias against the show. Maybe its the story. Perhaps Tolkien's finest work was his accounts in the 3rd age. After all, it was decided that the first trilogy would begin near the end of the overall story, not the beginning. Whatever the reason, S3 of The Rings of Power isnt drawing me in like I hoped. While I will watch the rest when available to see how things turn out, my expectations have been lowered quite a bit. There are seeds that could make make the remainder of S3 better than episodes 1-4. I suppose we will see. Looking forward to what the rest of you think. Perhaps my takes are off.
- Registered: 2025-12-02
- Posts: 192
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
jim1961 wrote:I was one of those that thoroughly enjoyed the 1st trilogy. But everything that has followed just hasn't grabbed me. Despite not being a fan of The Rings of Power through the first two seasons, I had gained some limited excitement about the coming of S3. Well, I just finished the first 4 episodes. Better than S2 for sure, but still nowhere close to what I like about the first trilogy. Maybe its me. Maybe I carry some invisible bias against the show. Maybe its the story. Perhaps Tolkien's finest work was his accounts in the 3rd age. After all, it was decided that the first trilogy would begin near the end of the overall story, not the beginning. Whatever the reason, S3 of The Rings of Power isnt drawing me in like I hoped. While I will watch the rest when available to see how things turn out, my expectations have been lowered quite a bit. There are seeds that could make make the remainder of S3 better than episodes 1-4. I suppose we will see. Looking forward to what the rest of you think. Perhaps my takes are off.
You're not alone. I know it's a silly point to make but the dwarvish women didn't have beards. When you start changing details of a story when does it end? A lot of TV producers and directors seem to want to put their own spin on things (see the witcher), but if they were good story writers they wouldn't be reproducing someone else's work and would be working on their own original story.

- jim1961
- Member
- Offline
- From: Texas
- Registered: 2025-02-24
- Posts: 276
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
Phanlix wrote:You're not alone. I know it's a silly point to make but the dwarvish women didn't have beards. When you start changing details of a story when does it end? A lot of TV producers and directors seem to want to put their own spin on things (see the witcher), but if they were good story writers they wouldn't be reproducing someone else's work and would be working on their own original story.
Are you saying the writers are what's wrong with the show?

- WilliamDrakeMcGregor
- Member
- Offline
- From: Germany
- Registered: 2016-06-10
- Posts: 1,436
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
jim1961 wrote:Are you saying the writers are what's wrong with the show?
In this case 100% - but to be fair, they have to compete with Tolkien himself. Peter Jackson had the advantage that The Lord of the Rings was a detailed story with all the material available to make the three movies and even more. Apart from that and The Hobbit, every other story we know - like The Simarillion - are notes, drafts and other scribbles of Tolkien that other people faithfully compiled into full books. But nevertheless they were not complete and detailed stories. To make movies or even a multi-season TV show out of it, it takes deep study & knowledge of the source material, great writing skills to translate the material into a script and the will and fortitude to keep it faithful to the original writers state of mind. That is something these writers seemingly did not manage to do so. P.S. The original trilogy are the greatest movies ever made. Period. No one can convince me otherwise and this will never change for me 
Deserved more runtime: Abbys | Dead Like Me | Devs | Firefly | Gangsta. | Jack of all Trades | Kevin (probably) saves the World | Lodge 49 | Mrs. Davis | NYC 22 | Powerless | Roadkill | Special Unit 2 | Stumptown | Surface | The Brave | The Crazy Ones | The Finder | The Middleman | Truth Seekers | Two Weeks to Live | Whiskey Cavalier https://next-episode.net/user/WilliamDrakeMcGregor/
- Registered: 2016-06-10
- Posts: 823
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
Just watched all 4 episode. Man do I wish I had a 4k tv. The scenery would have looked awesome. Cant wait to see the the rest. Beautiful series. When you get to be my age the one beautiful thing is your memory goes. I read the Hobbit etc. But cant remember squat. So I am not one of those die hard fans that complain when the show is not %100 book accurate.
- Registered: 2025-12-02
- Posts: 192
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote:jim1961 wrote:Are you saying the writers are what's wrong with the show?
In this case 100% - but to be fair, they have to compete with Tolkien himself. Peter Jackson had the advantage that The Lord of the Rings was a detailed story with all the material available to make the three movies and even more. Apart from that and The Hobbit, every other story we know - like The Simarillion - are notes, drafts and other scribbles of Tolkien that other people faithfully compiled into full books. But nevertheless they were not complete and detailed stories. To make movies or even a multi-season TV show out of it, it takes deep study & knowledge of the source material, great writing skills to translate the material into a script and the will and fortitude to keep it faithful to the original writers state of mind. That is something these writers seemingly did not manage to do so. P.S. The original trilogy are the greatest movies ever made. Period. No one can convince me otherwise and this will never change for me 
They honestly were absolute masterpieces. Fair point that they're competing with Tolkien and don't have a complete story to follow. But their job is to bring the world Tolkien created to life and by ignoring or changing details they're failing. I think my biggest complaint with this is I'm not being drawn in by the characters or story like I was with Frodo. I don't know if its the pacing or what the issue is, but I just can't connect with it.

- jim1961
- Member
- Offline
- From: Texas
- Registered: 2025-02-24
- Posts: 276
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote: Peter Jackson had the advantage that The Lord of the Rings was a detailed story with all the material available to make the three movies and even more.
Another disadvantage The Rings of Power suffers from is that several main characters have been portrayed previously. Viewers like myself want to see those characters be consistent. Galadriel, Elrond and Gandalf should feel like younger versions of who they were in the trilogy. They dont. They feel like different characters altogether, especially Galadriel. That said, its difficult to like them or get behind their actions.
- Registered: 2025-12-02
- Posts: 192
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
jim1961 wrote:WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote: Peter Jackson had the advantage that The Lord of the Rings was a detailed story with all the material available to make the three movies and even more.
Another disadvantage The Rings of Power suffers from is that several main characters have been portrayed previously. Viewers like myself want to see those characters be consistent. Galadriel, Elrond and Gandalf should feel like younger versions of who they were in the trilogy. They dont. They feel like different characters altogether, especially Galadriel. That said, its difficult to like them or get behind their actions.
Thank you, you just nailed on the head what I couldn't put my finger on. That's the exact issue with this show.
- Registered: 2008-09-22
- Posts: 137
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
Does it seem like they're thinking of killing the show off? The previous series had episode runs of 7 weeks, then 6 weeks but now we're squished into 3. OK, I hate the wait, but burn-off does happen when they're trying to kill things in TV So the big question is will there be a Season 4?

- WilliamDrakeMcGregor
- Member
- Offline
- From: Germany
- Registered: 2016-06-10
- Posts: 1,436
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
jim1961 wrote:They feel like different characters altogether, especially Galadriel.
Physically she should be at least taller - Galadriel is supposed to be the tallest female elf I think. And her behaviour should've been set thousands of years ago, so hard to imagine that she would change from the time the rings are created to Frodo's journey... But to me it's Elrond. The first time I saw Robert Aramayo I thought "who the F is that supposed to be?!"...the ridiculous hair and the obedient behaviour just didn't fit him at all....he is ~1500 years old. Not a character we saw before, but Gil-galad was also a huge disappointment for me. Benjamin Walker is not even remotely how I pictured him. I don't know what it is about him that makes him look absolutely ridiculous...maybe the hair, or the crown...not sure.
Deserved more runtime: Abbys | Dead Like Me | Devs | Firefly | Gangsta. | Jack of all Trades | Kevin (probably) saves the World | Lodge 49 | Mrs. Davis | NYC 22 | Powerless | Roadkill | Special Unit 2 | Stumptown | Surface | The Brave | The Crazy Ones | The Finder | The Middleman | Truth Seekers | Two Weeks to Live | Whiskey Cavalier https://next-episode.net/user/WilliamDrakeMcGregor/
162 Reply by jim1961 2026-11-12 17:59:47 (edited by jim1961 2026-11-12 18:25:15)

- jim1961
- Member
- Offline
- From: Texas
- Registered: 2025-02-24
- Posts: 276
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
WilliamDrakeMcGregor wrote:Physically she should be at least taller - Galadriel is supposed to be the tallest female elf I think. And her behaviour should've been set thousands of years ago, so hard to imagine that she would change from the time the rings are created to Frodo's journey... But to me it's Elrond. The first time I saw Robert Aramayo I thought "who the F is that supposed to be?!"...the ridiculous hair and the obedient behaviour just didn't fit him at all....he is ~1500 years old. Not a character we saw before, but Gil-galad was also a huge disappointment for me. Benjamin Walker is not even remotely how I pictured him. I don't know what it is about him that makes him look absolutely ridiculous...maybe the hair, or the crown...not sure.
As for physical appearances, I agree Elrond is the most off. But its their mannerisms, attitude and generally the way they carry themselves that bothers me the most. For me, the original trilogy is the establishing focal point to how I imagine these characters. Usually, when its a book adaptation, its the book version that I go back to. But not in this case. While its true I did read the books, it was a very long time ago and don't remember all that much. But more generally speaking, I would guess the vast majority of those viewing The Rings of Power also resort to the original trilogy as the baseline for comparison. And that works against this show in almost every way given the massive success that the original trilogy enjoyed. And yes, I agree that those original films were among the best ever made. Too tall an order for this series to live up to regardless of how much money is thrown at it.
- Registered: 2016-06-09
- Posts: 27
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
Each season gets worse and worse. Hero orc, elves that are no different from men,and stupid wire work that is so obvious they might aswel have left the wires in.
Posts: 151 to 163 of 163
Pages Previous 1 … 5 6 7
You must login or register to post a reply
|